
I try to be a conscious consumer, and I try to follow the social rules of the road and otherwise. However, I sometimes take the nerdview* of things, and this can cause problems in the day to day. Case in point. (see picture)
Do you see what I see? Where would you put your food waste? Where would you put your recyclable bottle?
Here are some of the problems I've identified with what are, to me, conflicting messages:
• The color of the bins.
• The size of the bins.
• The messaging on the bins.
• The placement of the bins.
• The accessibility (open-topped-ness) of the bins.
• The current contents of the open-topped bin.
• The presence of a liner in the bin.
For me, each of these criteria are weighted, based on my past experiences with garbage and recycling. For instance, a blue bin means recycling. But so does a closed-top bin. A large bin near a doorway means garbage, but so does an open topped bin with trash in it. Especially one with a liner. A bin labeled with "recycling" means that recyclable goods belong there. Especially when the bin also labeled with a qualifier, such as "CLEAN AND DRY ONLY."
If I were to rank these constraints, in order of importance to my categorical assessment, they'd probably look like this:
- Recycling bins are BLUE or GREEN, labeled, smaller than garbage bins, closed-topped, placed less prominently, and don't usually have liners.
- Garbage bins are not BLUE or GREEN, have liners, unmarked, larger than recycling bins, open topped, and placed prominently.
So what is to make of 2 equal sized bins, both having liners, both marked with recycling stickers, one blue and open-topped containing garbage and recyclables, one black and closed-topped with contents unknown, both placed prominently by a door?
I've taken some informal polls and the consensus is that the black, closed-topped bin, doubly marked is the recycling bin. I get this. But then why does the garbage bin have a recycling sticker on it. And why is it blue?

What to do? All I can say is this: the situation causes undo computational strain on my feeble brain.
Also, who painstakingly sorts this stuff? Every day I see both types of bins with mixed garbage/recycling in them, probably due to peoples' confusion in processing the mixed messages. I feel for these people, meaning all of us. Common sense does not always prevail.
*Why does nerdview seem to come up often in relation to garbage?
*** UPDATE! ***
Walking on campus, I found some more confusion to share:
On the left, below, we have a small, black, liner-ed, labeled, close-topped, garbage bin sitting beside a larger, blue, unlined, unlabeled, close-topped, GARBAGE bin. And in the next photo (right), we have THREE bins (whee) that mix up the constraints in more ways I can describe here. I think you're getting the idea.


On the left, below, we have a small, black, liner-ed, labeled, close-topped, garbage bin sitting beside a larger, blue, unlined, unlabeled, close-topped, GARBAGE bin. And in the next photo (right), we have THREE bins (whee) that mix up the constraints in more ways I can describe here. I think you're getting the idea.


No comments:
Post a Comment